Extraditions by Thailand Could Violate Treaty

Thailand could violate the terms of its extradition treaty with Cam­bo­dia if it returns two men accused of de­faming Prime Minister Hun Sen and inciting others to commit crimes, observers said Thursday.

National Police Commissioner Hok Lundy said Nov 4 that Thai au­thor­ities have agreed to arrest Ear Chan­na, deputy secretary-general of the Student Movement for Demo­cracy, and Man Nath, president of the Cambodian Indepen­dent Civil Servants Association, for defaming Hun Sen over the supplemental border agreement with Viet­nam.

Cambodian Defenders Project Ex­­e­cutive Director Sok Sam Oeun said the case was political and “ac­cording to this agreement, the Thai government cannot extradite them.”

The agreement states that extradition will not take place if “the host country considers the offense a political one.”

The only political offense exceptions are “assassination or attempted assassination of the head of state, head of government, or their family members,” the treaty states in Chapter Three.

The host country must reject an ex­­tradition request if it “has clear rea­sons to prove that the proposed ex­tradition by the proposing party is to use legal procedures [against] or to torture the accused because of race, religion, nationality or the pol­itical views of the accused.”

Om Yentieng, an adviser to Hun Sen, said the government is fully aware of the treaty’s text.

“[The government is] not ignorant of the law,” Om Yentieng said. “We understand the treaty. We did not request their extradition be­cause of political issues,” he said.

Justice Minister Ang Vong Va­tha­na said the charges against the pair are criminal rather than political.

“They have been charged for trying to cause problems in the country,” he said. “They were trying to pro­voke other people.”

Sok Sam Oeun said he expected that the case would be sent to the Thai courts, which will issue a ruling on whether the case is political and whether they can be extradited.

Sam Rainsy Party activist Sok Yoeun fled to Thailand in 1998 after be­­ing accused of taking part in a fail­ed rocket attack on Hun Sen’s convoy in Siem Reap province. Ar­rested in Thailand, Sok Yoeun spent four years in prison amid lengthy extradition proceedings. He was eventually granted asylum to Finland.

“The case will be reviewed by the executive and judicial branches of both governments,” said Thai Am­bas­sador Piyawat Niyomrerks.

 

Related Stories

Latest News

The Weekly DispatchA weekly newsletter from The Cambodia Daily delivering news, analysis and opinion to your inbox. Published every Friday at 11:30am. Sign up today.