Logging Industry Debate Hushed by Holidays

Reaction to Prime Minister Hun Sen’s threat this week to re­place independent forestry monitor Global Witness has been muted by the holidays as officials from the World Bank and elsewhere stayed away from their of­fices and public comment Thurs­day.

NGO officials working in the log­ging industry stayed low as well this week for fear that the prime minister’s threat to revoke visas would be widened to in­clude others who support the work of Glo­­bal Witness, one NGO official said. Global Witness Director Eva Gal­a­bru, meanwhile, had no comment Thursday on whether the NGO planned to issue an apol­ogy to the government, a tactic that saved the NGO from ex­pulsion in early 2001 after it was ac­cused of intentionally embarrassing the government.

“That’s very premature [to talk about an apology],” Galabru said. “The ball is very much in [the gov­ernment’s] court.”

Only the latest flare-up in the often thorny relationship be­tween the government and its in­depen­dent forestry monitor, this week’s threat stems from a violent con­fron­tation Dec 5 in front of the De­part­ment of Forestry be­tween villagers and police. One vil­lager died shortly after the confrontation, though his death could not be definitively linked to the police crackdown. Global Witness and others have said police used violence to suppress the villagers, who had come to Phnom Penh to learn more about logging company plans for the forests in their homelands; government officials have said Global Witness exaggerated the confrontation.

If the prime minister carried out his threats to replace Global Wit­ness as forestry monitor, to re­voke the visas of the foreign staff of Global Witness and to prevent Cambodian nationals, in­clud­ing Galabru, from continuing their work, he could set off the same conditions that lead the In­ter­national Monetary Fund to suspend $60 million in aid in 1996.

The international aid agency said at the time that rampant logging was beyond government control and would require a strong and independent monitor to oversee logging practices. The IMF funds were restored when the government hired Global Wit­ness as its independent monitor. World Bank officials could not be reached for comment Thurs­day, but several ob­servers, in­cluding two US senators, have called on the international organization to cut funding to Cambo­dia because of the widening rift over Global Witness. The government continues to work on management plans that will eventually lead to the re­sumption of logging, which Hun Sen halted one year ago.

Ty Sokhun, director of the For­estry Department, said Thursday that the public would be allowed to make comments on the management plans until Jan 31.

, two months beyond the original comment period.


Related Stories

Latest News

The Weekly DispatchA weekly newsletter from The Cambodia Daily delivering news, analysis and opinion to your inbox. Published every Friday at 11:30am. Sign up today.