Judge Resigns KR Court Over Gov’t Pressure

International Co-Investigating Judge Siegfried Blunk has re­signed from his position at the Khmer Rouge tribunal in the face of government interference in the court and adamant opposition to investigations into two more cases against Khmer Rouge re­gime suspects.

The move came less than a week after Human Rights Watch called for Mr Blunk’s resignation over failing to properly investigate the two cases, which are known as 003 and 004.

In a statement released by Judge Blunk yesterday, he re­ferred to three comments made by Prime Minister Hun Sen, In­formation Minister Khieu Ka­nharith and Foreign Minister Hor Namhong that have warned judges at the tribunal away from pursuing investigations into cases 003 and 004.

“Although the International Co-Investigating Judge will not let himself be influenced by such statements, his ability to withstand such pressure by Govern­ment officials and to perform his duties independently, could al­ways be called in doubt, and this would also call in doubt the in­tegrity of the whole proceedings in Cases 003 and 004,” Judge Blunk wrote.

The resignation marks an end to months of heated criticism against Judge Blunk, and his national counterpart You Bunleng, for refusing to thoroughly investigate the two cases. Both Judge Blunk and Judge Bunleng have stopped investigating Case 003 without having interviewed suspects or examined crime sites.

Commenting on the resignation, Council of Ministers spokesman Phay Siphan said that Judge Blunk’s departure from the tribunal showed that he had misunderstood the principles of a mixed court.

“He [Judge Blunk] failed to understand the wisdom of setting up the ECCC which is the partnership between the government and the UN,” he said. “We still stand on our ground regarding the ECCC. There will be no case 003 or 004.”

“The government doesn’t want failure that is why it only allows case 002 to take place.”

Prime Minister Hun Sen has publicly opposed the two cases for years and in October 2010 bluntly told UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon that the cases were “not allowed.”

In his statement Judge Blunk’s also said that he had initiated contempt of court proceedings against Mr Kanharith for saying in May that “If they want to go into Case 003 and 004, they should just pack their bags and leave.”

Judge Blunk said he “expected this to be a warning to other government officials.”

Last week, however, Foreign Minister Hor Namhong was quoted as saying that the arrest of more Khmer Rouge leaders “must be decided by Cambodia”, the statement added.

UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon’s spokesman Martin Nesirky said yesterday that the UN is urgently working to get Judge Blunk’s replacement, Swiss crimes investigator Laurent Kasper-Ansermet, to take over work at the tribunal as soon as possible.

“The United Nations has consistently emphasized that the ECCC must be permitted to proceed with its work without interference from any entity, including the Royal Government of Cambodia, donor States or civil society,” Mr Nesirky said in an email.

In a message sent via the social networking site Facebook, Mr Kanharith denied that the government had interfered with the court.

“He [Judge Blunk] reject the blame on others while he failed to cooperate with other colleagues at the Court,” Mr Kanharith said. “He must read carefully the convention between the [government] and UN.”

Elisabeth Simonneau Fort, lead civil party co-lawyer, said that Mr Blunk’s resignation would actually improve the climate at the tribunal as Case 002 begins.

“I could say it was necessary at this stage,” she said. “But it is not a resolution to every problem.”

International Co-Prosecutor Andrew Cayley said that he would continue to press for a proper investigation and due process in Cases 003 and 004.

“I do not think Judge Blunk’s resignation signals the end of the court since the trial of Case 002 will soon begin,” Mr Cayley said in an email.

Human rights groups, however, voiced frustration that not enough was being done to address concerns over political interference in the court.

Youk Chhang, director of the Documentation Center of Cambodia, said that Judge Blunk’s resignation alone was not good enough and the UN must conduct an independent investigation into the office of the co-investigating judges.

“This is a court, not a theater,” he said.

 

Related Stories

Latest News

The Weekly DispatchA new weekly newsletter from The Cambodia Daily delivering news, analysis and opinion to your inbox. Published every Friday at 11:30am. Sign up today.