Court-Ordered Eviction in Long-Running R’kiri Dispute

Cambodia’s farmers remain too poor to pay income and property taxes, Prime Minister Hun Sen said yesterday, responding to calls from international organizations for the government to step up its tax collection efforts.

“Over the last few days, I’ve heard about an IMF appeal for the government to increase taxes since the tax revenues in our country are lower than in neighboring countries,” said Mr Hun Sen, speaking at a graduation ceremony at the National Institute of Education in Phnom Penh.

“It is true the we have yet to collect property taxes or other taxes from farmers and I have told the IMF, the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank that Cambodian farmers can’t be asked for tax yet and must be helped.”

On Sunday, the International Monetary Fund’s Asia and Pacific Department director, Anoop Singh, said at a press conference that “important steps are needed in Cambodia’s case to raise the tax ratio.” Mr Singh did not mention farmers, but estimated that Cambodia’s ratio of tax revenue to GDP lagged 5 to 7 percent behind most other countries in similar states of development.

In July, the UN Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific released a report claiming the government would need to increase its tax collection ability in order to maintain robust spending. According to the ESCAP report, Cambodian tax revenues amount to only 11 percent of GDP, compared to an average of 20 percent in developing countries worldwide.

According to an ADB report released in July, public debt in Cambodia rose from 16 percent of GDP in 2008 to 22 percent of GDP last year.

“One of the constant recommendations from the international donor community is to broaden the tax base to include more people under the system,” Eric Vanderbruggen, a government and World Bank tax consultant, said on Monday.

Officials from the General Department of Taxation could not be reached for comment yesterday.

Mr Hun Sen said in his speech that the government is trying to determine how to pay for irrigation systems without collecting taxes or service fees from farmers.

“When we think about the economy in general, we must invest in improving our agricultural sector,” he said.

Ministry of Water Resources Secretary of State Phan Sareth said yesterday that lack of government funding has made expanding the irrigation network that currently covers roughly 60 percent of Cambodia’s farmland increasingly difficult.

“Previously, we’ve received funds from foreigners to improve irrigation, but this is not enough to extend our system,” said Mr Sareth.

 

By Kuch Naren

the cambodia daily

 

Ratanakkiri Provincial Court yesterday sent more than 30 police, military police and RCAF soldiers to evict ten families involved in a long-running land dispute, removing at least one home from a contested plot of land in the heart of Banlung City.

The eviction was ordered by the Supreme Court earlier this month, when it ruled that the wife of a former provincial official owned a 25-meter by 65-meter plot of land in Laban Siek commune.

Kuy Yan, the wife of Suong Piseth, the former director of the provincial department of public works, lodged a complaint against her brother-in-law Doeurn Chan in 2005, alleging he had unlawfully grabbed land belonging to her husband.

Deputy provincial prosecutor Ros Saram confirmed that he had led the armed forces in carrying out yesterday’s eviction.

He said the heavy reinforcements, which included a water truck in case of attempted arson, were necessary because of the potential for violence.

Although only Mr Chan’s house was removed yesterday, Mr Saram said he would return today to evict the remaining nine families.

Mr Chan maintained yesterday that his brother, Mr Piseth, had transferred ownership of the land to him in exchange for the elimination of a $6,000 debt, but said they had not documented the transaction because they were family and trusted each other.

“I first protested to stop those officials from moving my home, but I could not because they had armed forces,” he said.

“I am not opposing the Supreme Court’s eviction order, but the order has been made without justice,” said Nuon Mol, a provincial police officer who says he has lived on the disputed land since 1987.

Mr Mol, who is seeking $20,000 in compensation for the eviction, claimed he had legal documents signed and stamped by local authorities proving that he purchased his land legally from Mr Chan in 1987.

However, copies of those documents obtained yesterday indicated that the sale was actually made in 2007.

Mr Mol added that none of the ten evicted families had been summoned for questioning by the provincial court, the Court of Appeal or the Supreme Court.

Ms Yan and Mr Piseth could not be reached for comment yesterday.

 

Related Stories

Latest News

The Weekly DispatchA new weekly newsletter from The Cambodia Daily delivering news, analysis and opinion to your inbox. Published every Friday at 11:30am. Sign up today.